Community gardening: cultivating subjectivities, space, and justice

• Published in: Local environment 2017-09, Vol.22 (9), p.1142-1158
• Main Author: Barron, Jennifer
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Citizens; Communities; Community; Community gardens; Cultivation; Decentralization; Devolution; Entrepreneurship; Food; Food justice; Gardening; Gardens; Gardens & gardening; Justice; Labor theory of value; Lenses; Neoliberalism; Privatization; Seeds; spatial justice; subjectivities; Underwriting; volunteerism
• ISSN: 1354-9839; 1469-6711
• DOI: 10.1080/13549839.2016.1169518

Community gardens have been lauded for being inherently resistant to neoliberalism and criticised for underwriting it. To move beyond this either/or debate, we need to employ more focused lenses and specify both the processes of neoliberalisation at play and the outcomes they can produce. This paper explores the ways in which neoliberal processes of privatisation, state entrepreneurialism, and devolution intersect with community gardens, and the subjectivities that may be cultivated, the spaces that may be created and the types of justice that may be advanced as a result. It argues that certain characteristics and orientations of gardens are more conducive to resisting neoliberalism. These include the cultivation of producer, citizen, and activist subjectivities (over those of consumer, entrepreneur, and volunteer); the elevation of the use value of shared lived space (over a site's potential exchange value) and the advancement of spatial justice through community access to non-privatised space; and food justice, through non-commodified means of obtaining food. Holding these ends in mind can help ensure that proponents of community gardening sow the seeds of the fruits they most wish to reap.