An improved survey method for monitoring population trends of Golden-winged Warblers and other patchily distributed birds

• Published in: Journal of field ornithology 2017-12, Vol.88 (4), p.387-398
• Main Authors: Wood, Eric M., Swarthout, Sara Barker, Hochachka, Wesley M., Rohrbaugh, Ronald W., Rosenberg, Kenneth V., Rodewald, Amanda D.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Animal breeding; Appalachian Region; Birds; Blue‐winged Warbler; Breeding; Breeding Bird Survey; Breeding seasons; Conservation; Design; Detection; Dynamics; Habitats; Mobbing; Monitoring; Monitoring methods; Mountains; Ornithological Methods; Playback; Polls & surveys; Population; Population changes; Population decline; Probability theory; Rare species; spatially balanced sampling; Species; Survey design; Surveying; Surveys; Tracking; Trends; Vermivora; Vermivora chrysoptera; Vermivora cyanoptera; Vermivora pinus; Wildlife conservation
• ISSN: 0273-8570; 1557-9263
• DOI: 10.1111/jofo.12220

Conventional surveys designed to monitor common and widespread species may fail to adequately track population changes of rare or patchily distributed species that are often or high conservation concern. We evaluated the performance of a new monitoring approach that employs both a spatially balanced sampling design and a targeted survey protocol designed to estimate population trends of one such patchily distributed species, the Golden-winged Warbler (Vermivora chrysoptera), in the Appalachian Mountains Bird Conservation Region (BCR 28), USA. Our spatially balanced survey consisted of 105 sample quads (one-quarter Delorme Atlas pages) across the current range of Golden-winged Warblers within BCR 28, each with five sample points located in early successional habitat. From 2009 to 2013, collaborators visited each sample point once per year during the peak breeding season and conducted a 17-min survey consisting of passive observation and playback of conspecific songs and mobbing vocalizations. We used multi-season, single-species occupancy models to estimate probability of quad occupancy, detection probability, and occupancy dynamics for Golden-winged Warblers and closely related Blue-winged Warblers (Vermivora cyanopterd). Our survey protocol resulted in high estimates of detection probability for Golden-winged (92%) and Blue-winged (79%) warblers, with 47% and 56% of quads estimated to be initially occupied, respectively. Derived population trend estimates (λ) indicated an average decline in population of 6% for Golden-winged Warblers and 7% for Blue-winged Warblers, resulting in estimated 21% and 22% declines, respectively, in quad occupancy after 5 yr. Our results demonstrate that coupling a spatially balanced survey design in appropriate habitat with a playback protocol to increase detection rates is a viable strategy for tracking populations of Golden-winged Warblers in the Appalachian Mountains BCR. Similar survey methods should be considered for other rare, declining, or patchily distributed bird species that require targeted monitoring. Estudios convencionales diseñados para monitorear especies comunes y de amplia distribución pueden fallar en rastrear adecuadamente poblaciones de especies raras de distribución en parches que son con frecuencia de alto interés para la conservación. Evaluamos el desempeño de una nueva estrategia de monitoreo que emplea tanto un diseño espacial balanceado como un protocolo de estudio dirigido diseñado para estimar ten