Evaluation of the seismic retrofitting of an unreinforced masonry building using numerical modeling and ambient vibration measurements

• Published in: Engineering structures 2018-03, Vol.158, p.124-135
• Main Authors: Michel, Clotaire, Karbassi, Amin, Lestuzzi, Pierino
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Acoustic insulation; Ambient vibration measurement; Applied element method modeling; Aseismic buildings; Beams (structural); Concrete; Concrete construction; Damage grade; Deformation; Deformation effects; Deformation mechanisms; Earthquake damage; Evolution; Failure mechanisms; Ground motion; Historical buildings; Masonry; Mathematical models; Nonlinear time-history analysis; Reinforced concrete; Reinforcing steels; Retrofitting; Seismic activity; Seismic engineering; Seismic response; Seismic retrofitting; Slabs; Steel; Three dimensional models; Unreinforced masonry buildings; Vibration
• ISSN: 0141-0296; 1873-7323
• DOI: 10.1016/j.engstruct.2017.12.016

•Assessment of a retrofitted URM building with innovative approaches.•Retrofitting work was monitored in the linear range under ambient vibrations.•3D non-linear modelling is used to assess the retrofitting solution.•Improvement in seismic safety following the studied retrofitting method is limited. Ambient vibration measurements and 3-D nonlinear time-history numerical modeling are used to assess the retrofitting measures conducted in a 6-story unreinforced masonry building (URM) built in the end of the 19th century in Switzerland. Retrofitting measures were taken in order to improve the soundproofing and possibly the seismic performance of the building. Reinforced concrete (RC) footings were added under the walls and horizontal steel beams were added to link the walls together with a RC slab at each floor, though the wooden beams were left in place. Several ambient vibration recordings were performed before, during and after the retrofitting work in order to monitor the evolution of the dynamic behavior of the structure. Moreover, numerical models representing the state of the building before and after the retrofit work have been developed to perform nonlinear dynamic analyses using various ground motion records. The change in the modal vibration frequencies, mode shapes, and failure mechanism are presented and discussed in further details. According to ambient vibration measurements, the performed retrofitting resulted in an increase of about 25% of the fundamental frequency. From the results of both the numerical modeling and the ambient vibration measurements, it is confirmed that the in-plane behavior of the slabs evolved from non-rigid floors with in-plane deformation to rigid floors with diaphragm effects. The ambient vibration measurements show that the new stiff slabs could lead to torsion behavior in the building as the result of the diaphragm effect and to higher seismic demand. However, the numerical models show that the displacement capacity of the building increases as a result of those new stiff slabs. Consequently, higher deformation capacity, indicated by the inter-story drift values, on average, are observed for all the damage grades in the post-retrofit state of the building. Finally, the overall seismic safety was only slightly improved.