Welcoming Immigrants with Similar Occupational Interests: Experimental Survey Evidence from Hong Kong

• Published in: Political studies 2017-06, Vol.65 (2), p.391-412
• Main Authors: Lee, Siu-yau, Vyas, Lina, Chou, Kee-lee
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Attitudes; Competition; Hostility; Immigrants; Immigration; Indigenous peoples; Job security; Labor market; Occupational prestige; Polls & surveys; Prestige; Residents; Self interest; Threats
• ISSN: 0032-3217; 1467-9248
• DOI: 10.1177/0032321716654923

Recent studies in America and Europe suggest that individual economic self-interest plays little role in explaining individual attitudes towards immigrants. A key piece of evidence for this proposition is that natives do not show particular hostility towards immigrants whose skill levels are similar to their own. We conducted an experimental survey of Hong Kong residents to examine their attitudes towards immigrants from Mainland China. We found that positive attitudes towards low-skilled immigrants were more prevalent among local labourers – whose job security would presumably be under greater threat from them – than among executives and professionals. Similarly, the premium attached to highly skilled immigrants increases significantly with locals’ occupational prestige, suggesting that immigrants are more likely to find support among natives who share similar occupational interests. Our results remain robust even after controlling for a range of potential explanatory variables. We conclude with a critical discussion of the use of skill levels to estimate the occupational interests of natives and assess the value of relying on the conventional labour market competition model to generate hypotheses about the role of economic self-interest in shaping immigration preferences.