CPU and/or GPU: Revisiting the GPU Vs. CPU Myth

• Published in: arXiv.org 2013-03
• Main Authors: Kothapalli, Kishore, Banerjee, Dip Sankar, Narayanan, P J, Sood, Surinder, Bahl, Aman Kumar, Sharma, Shashank, Lad, Shrenik, Singh, Krishna Kumar, Matam, Kiran, Bharadwaj, Sivaramakrishna, Nigam, Rohit, Sakurikar, Parikshit, Deshpande, Aditya, Misra, Ishan, Choudhary, Siddharth, Gupta, Shubham
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Accelerators; Central processing units; Computing costs; CPUs; Graphics processing units; Image processing; Platforms
• ISSN: 2331-8422

Parallel computing using accelerators has gained widespread research attention in the past few years. In particular, using GPUs for general purpose computing has brought forth several success stories with respect to time taken, cost, power, and other metrics. However, accelerator based computing has signifi- cantly relegated the role of CPUs in computation. As CPUs evolve and also offer matching computational resources, it is important to also include CPUs in the computation. We call this the hybrid computing model. Indeed, most computer systems of the present age offer a degree of heterogeneity and therefore such a model is quite natural. We reevaluate the claim of a recent paper by Lee et al.(ISCA 2010). We argue that the right question arising out of Lee et al. (ISCA 2010) should be how to use a CPU+GPU platform efficiently, instead of whether one should use a CPU or a GPU exclusively. To this end, we experiment with a set of 13 diverse workloads ranging from databases, image processing, sparse matrix kernels, and graphs. We experiment with two different hybrid platforms: one consisting of a 6-core Intel i7-980X CPU and an NVidia Tesla T10 GPU, and another consisting of an Intel E7400 dual core CPU with an NVidia GT520 GPU. On both these platforms, we show that hybrid solutions offer good advantage over CPU or GPU alone solutions. On both these platforms, we also show that our solutions are 90% resource efficient on average. Our work therefore suggests that hybrid computing can offer tremendous advantages at not only research-scale platforms but also the more realistic scale systems with significant performance gains and resource efficiency to the large scale user community.