An Approach for Conducting Actionable Research With Extreme Teams

• Published in: Journal of management 2018-09, Vol.44 (7), p.2740-2765
• Main Authors: Bell, Suzanne T., Fisher, David M., Brown, Shanique G., Mann, Kristin E.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Crews; Disaster management; Disaster relief; Evidence based research; Mixed methods research; Researchers; Task performance; Teams
• ISSN: 0149-2063; 1557-1211
• DOI: 10.1177/0149206316653805

Extreme teams complete their tasks in unconventional performance environments and have serious consequences associated with failure. Examples include disaster relief teams, special operations teams, and astronaut crews. The unconventional performance environments within which these teams operate require researchers to carefully consider the context during the research process. These environments may also create formidable challenges to the research process, including constraining data collection and sample sizes. Given the serious consequences associated with failure, however, the challenges must be navigated so that the management of extreme teams can be evidence based. We present an approach for conducting actionable research on extreme teams. Our approach is an extension of mixed-methods research that is particularly well suited for emphasizing context. The approach guides researchers on how to integrate the local context into the research process, which allows for actionable recommendations. At the same time, our approach applies an intentionally broad framework for organizing context, which can serve as a mechanism through which the results of research on extreme teams can be meaningfully accumulated and integrated across teams. Finally, our approach and description of steps address the unique challenges common in extreme-team research. While developed with extreme teams in mind, we view our general approach as applicable to more traditional teams when the features of the context that impinge on team functioning are not adequately represented by typical descriptions of context in the literature and the goal is actionable research for the teams in question.