Agroecological Pest Management in the City: Experiences from California and Chiapas

• Published in: Sustainability 2018-06, Vol.10 (6), p.2068
• Main Authors: Morales, Helda, Ferguson, Bruce, Marín, Linda, Gutiérrez, Dario, Bichier, Peter, Philpott, Stacy
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Abundance; Agricultural ecosystems; Agricultural land; Agricultural management; Barren lands; Biological control; Food security; Gardens; Gardens & gardening; Ground cover; Ichneumonoidea; Land cover; Land use; Landscape; Natural enemies; Parasitoids; Pest control; Pests; Predators; Prey; Provisioning; Sustainability; Trees; Urban agriculture; Urban areas; Urban environments; Vegetation; Vegetation cover
• ISSN: 2071-1050; 2071-1050
• DOI: 10.3390/su10062068

Urban gardens are a prominent part of agricultural systems, providing food security and access within cities; however, we still lack sufficient knowledge and general principles about how to manage pests in urban agroecosystems in distinct regions. We surveyed natural enemies (ladybeetles and parasitoids) and conducted sentinel pest removal experiments to explore local management factors and landscape characteristics that influence the provisioning of pest control services in California, USA, and Chiapas, Mexico. We worked in 29 gardens across the two locations. In each location, we collected data on garden vegetation, floral availability, ground cover management, and the percentage of natural, urban, and agricultural land cover in the surrounding landscape. We sampled ladybeetles, Chalcidoidea, and Ichneumonoidea parasitoids with sticky traps, and monitored the removal of three different pest species. Ladybeetle abundance did not differ between locations; abundance decreased with garden size and with tree cover and increased with herbaceous richness, floral abundance, and barren land cover. Chalcicoidea and Ichneumonoidea parasitoids were more abundant in Chiapas. Chalcicoidea abundance decreased with herbaceous richness and with urban cover. Ichneumonoidea abundance increased with mulch and bare ground cover, garden size, garden age, and with agriculture land cover but decreased with tree richness and urban cover. Predators removed between 15–100% of sentinel prey within 24 h but prey removal was greater in California. Generally, prey removal increased with vegetation diversity, floral abundance, mulch cover, and urban land cover, but declined with vegetation cover and bare ground. Although some factors had consistent effects on natural enemies and pest control in the two locations, many did not; thus, we still need more comparative work to further develop our understanding of general principles governing conservation biological control in urban settings.