Destituent power in the European Union: On the limits of a negativistic logic of constitutional politics

• Published in: Journal of international political theory 2019-02, Vol.15 (1), p.82-99
• Main Author: Patberg, Markus
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Democratization; Hegemony; Neoliberalism; Power; Protest movements; Resistance; Sovereignty; Treaties
• ISSN: 1755-0882; 1755-1722
• DOI: 10.1177/1755088218806916

Since the euro crisis, protest movements present the European Union as a neoliberal hegemony that undermines democracy and prevents progressive reforms. They call for acts of resistance and partial disintegration to force a renegotiation of the treaties. In this article, I ask whether these ‘disruptive’ political strategies can be defended as a democratic practice of constitutional politics. To that end, I turn to the notion of destituent power, according to which opposition to or withdrawal from public authority can function as a legitimate trigger for constitutional change. I systematise the emerging debate on destituent power and discuss the plausibility of competing approaches. I argue that destituent power is best understood as grounded in popular sovereignty. It denotes the right to dismantle constitutional orders without the intention to construct new ones. While this idea supports some of the acts of contestation proposed by European protest movements, it faces a lure towards the jurisgenerative dimension of constituent power. Ultimately, the potential of a purely negativistic logic of constitutional politics is limited.