The importance of robust design methodology: case study of the infamous GM ignition switch recall

While a systematic quality strategy is of crucial importance for the success of manufacturing companies, the universal applicability and effectiveness of implemented quality management practices were called into question by a number of major product recalls in recent years. This article seeks to ill...

Full description

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Published in:Research in engineering design 2018, Vol.29 (1), p.39-53
Main Authors: Eifler, Tobias, Howard, Thomas J.
Format: Article
Language:English
Subjects:
Automobile industry
Automobiles
Automotive engineering
CAE) and Design
Computer-Aided Engineering (CAD
Design analysis
Engineering
Engineering Design
Ignition
Original Paper
Product development
Product recalls
Quality management
Robust design
Robustness
Sensitivity analysis
Citations: Items that this one cites
Items that cite this one
Online Access:Get full text
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
Description
Summary:While a systematic quality strategy is of crucial importance for the success of manufacturing companies, the universal applicability and effectiveness of implemented quality management practices were called into question by a number of major product recalls in recent years. This article seeks to illustrate how already simple analyses and early stage design methods can help to better understand one of the potential reasons for these failures, namely the variation inherent in manufacturing, assembly, and use processes. Usually thoroughly controlled in production, it seems as if particularly the risk of unanticipated variation effects remain largely underestimated and thus unaccounted for in design practice, sometimes with disastrous consequences. To foster the awareness of this variation and to illustrate the benefits of its early consideration in product development, this paper reviews one of the most infamous recalls in automotive history, that of the GM ignition switch, from the perspective of Robust Design. It is investigated if available Robust Design methods such as sensitivity analysis, tolerance stack-ups, design clarity, etc. would have been suitable to account for the performance variation, which has led to a number of fatal product defects and the recall of 30 million vehicles. Furthermore, the disclosed legal case files were examined, offering a unique opportunity to examine how technical malfunctioning of the ignition switch could stay undetected long enough to result in fatalities.
ISSN:0934-9839
1435-6066
DOI:10.1007/s00163-017-0251-x