Medial and lateral meniscus have a different role in kinematics of the ACL-deficient knee: a systematic review

• Published in: Journal of ISAKOS 2019-09, Vol.4 (5), p.233
• Main Authors: Grassi, Alberto, Dal Fabbro, Giacomo, Di Paolo, Stefano, Stefanelli, Federico, Macchiarola, Luca, Lucidi, Gian Andrea, Zaffagnini, Stefano
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Arthritis; Biomechanics; Kinematics; Knee; Ligaments; Localization; Sports injuries; Studies; Systematic review
• ISSN: 2059-7754; 2059-7762
• DOI: 10.1136/jisakos-2019-000293

ImportanceMeniscal tears are frequently associated with anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury and the correct management of this kind of lesion during ACL-reconstruction procedure is critical for the restoration of knee kinematics. Although the importance of meniscus in knee biomechanics is generally accepted, the influence of medial and lateral meniscus in stability of ACL-deficient knee is still unclear.ObjectiveThe aim of this study was to review literature, which analysed effects in cadaveric specimens of meniscal tear and meniscectomy of medial and lateral meniscus on laxity in the ACL-deficient knee.Evidence reviewAuthors performed a systematic search for cadaveric studies analysing the effect of medial and lateral meniscus tears or resection on kinematics of ACL-deficient knee. Extracted data included year of publications, number of human cadaver knee specimens, description of apparatus testing and instrumented kinematic evaluation, testing protocol and results.FindingsAuthors identified 18 studies that met inclusion and exclusion criteria of current review. The major finding of the review was that the works included reported a difference role of medial and lateral meniscus in restraining ACL-deficient knee laxity. Medial meniscus tear or resection resulted in a significant increase of anterior tibial displacement. Lateral meniscus lesions or meniscectomy on the other hand significantly increased rotation and translation under a coupled valgus stress and internal-rotation torque/pivot shift test.ConclusionsMedial and lateral meniscus have a different role in stabilising the ACL-deficient knee: while the medial meniscus functions as a critical secondary stabilisers of anterior tibial translation under an anterior/posterior load, lateral meniscus appears to be a more important restraint of rotational and dynamic laxity.Level of evidenceLevel IV, systematic review of level I–IV studies.