Optimizing ventilation: Theoretical study on increasing rates in offices to maximize occupant productivity with constrained additional energy use

• Published in: Building and environment 2019-12, Vol.166, p.106314, Article 106314
• Main Authors: Ben-David, Tom, Rackes, Adams, Lo, L. James, Wen, Jin, Waring, Michael S.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Absenteeism; Air quality; Air quality standards; Building energy; Buildings; Constraints; Energy; Energy budget; Energy consumption; Healthy buildings; Indoor air pollution; Indoor air quality; Indoor environments; Occupant performance; Office buildings; Optimization; Pareto optimization; Productivity; Simulation; Trajectory optimization; Ventilation; Ventilation control; Weather forecasting
• ISSN: 0360-1323; 1873-684X
• DOI: 10.1016/j.buildenv.2019.106314

Ventilation affects building energy use and indoor air quality, with minimum rates prescribed by standards. However, research has demonstrated positive outcomes associated with increasing ventilation, including occupant productivity from increased work performance and reduced absenteeism. Herein, a novel ventilation strategy was proposed and simulated for offices, which optimized day-averaged ventilation rates over an annual time horizon to provide maximal amounts of outdoor air and so maximize occupant productive work hours, within varying energy use constraints. Energy use and productivity were often influenced by ventilation oppositely, so results were Pareto optimal. This optimization methodology was simulated in three locations for an average- and high-performance small office building, considering users with varying levels of confidence in ventilation-productivity relationships. To contextualize potential optimization impacts, four annual energy budgets were first determined for a typical year at constant ventilation rates of 8.5, 10, 20, and 30 L/s/occupant, and then for those four cases, day-averaged ventilation rates were optimized over annual trajectories considering the constrained energy budgets. Among all simulated cases, lost productive hours due to lower ventilation at constant rates were halved when using the optimized higher annual rates, with a gain of ~20 h/year per occupant on average, amounting to approximately $48/m2 at standard occupant density and mean wage. Offline optimization results were used to develop heuristic rules to predict a ventilation rate for any single day based on weather forecast that would adhere to a building- and climate-specific Pareto optimization, opening avenues for future control strategies that use this framework in real buildings. •Increases in office-worker productive hours are associated with increasing ventilation.•Ventilation was optimized to increase productivity under various energy constraints.•Ventilation could vary each day of the year to maximize total outdoor air delivered.•Simulations perturbed variables of energy budgets, locations, building types, and user profiles.•On average, optimized ventilation rates reduced lost productive hours by one-half.