The Acquisition of Quality Information in a Supply Chain with Voluntary vs. Mandatory Disclosure

• Published in: Production and operations management 2020-03, Vol.29 (3), p.595-616
• Main Authors: Cao, Huan, Guan, Xu, Fan, Tijun, Zhou, Li
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Disclosure; game theory; information acquisition; mandatory disclosure; Manufacturing; Product quality; quality; supply chain; Supply chains; voluntary disclosure
• ISSN: 1059-1478; 1937-5956
• DOI: 10.1111/poms.13130

Quality information acquisition and disclosure have significant ramifications for supply chain members. This study investigates the interaction between a manufacturer’s product quality information acquisition and different product quality information disclosure systems in a supply chain wherein the manufacturer can privately acquire the precise quality information of its product by affordable means initially. We consider two different quality information disclosure systems for the quality information acquisition: voluntary disclosure (i.e., the manufacturer determines whether to disclose the quality information that he has acquired), and mandatory disclosure (i.e., the manufacturer is mandated to disclose the quality information that he has acquired). We examine the effects of voluntary disclosure and mandatory disclosure on the equilibrium strategies and payoffs of the manufacturer and the retailer and on the consumer surplus. It is shown that mandatory disclosure significantly reduces the manufacturer’s incentive to acquire the precise product quality information and leads to a reduction in the product quality information that the retailer and the consumers can receive. Interestingly, although the manufacturer is ex ante better off, the retailer’s ex ante payoff and the expected consumer surplus become lower under mandatory disclosure, as opposed to voluntary disclosure of product quality information.