James Lind Alliance research priorities: should diet and exercise be used as an alternative to drugs for the management of type 2 diabetes or alongside them?

• Published in: Diabetic medicine 2020-04, Vol.37 (4), p.564-572
• Main Authors: England, C. Y., Andrews, R. C.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Blood pressure; Body weight loss; Cardiovascular diseases; Cardiovascular system; Cholesterol; Clinical trials; Diabetes; Diabetes mellitus (non-insulin dependent); Diet; Drug therapy; Exercise; Medical research; Physical activity; Physical fitness; Physical training
• ISSN: 0742-3071; 1464-5491
• DOI: 10.1111/dme.14217

Aim To review evidence on whether diet and exercise should be used as an alternative to drug therapy for the management of type 2 diabetes or alongside. Method We present a narrative review that draws on evidence from other systematic reviews and meta‐analyses, narrative reviews, trials and cohort studies. We focused mainly on glycaemic control rather than control of blood pressure or cholesterol. Results Good‐quality dietary advice that results in weight loss of >5% and physical activity interventions of >150 min/week of moderate to vigorous physical activity, combined with resistance exercise, can produce improvements in HbA1c similar to those produced by the addition of glucose‐lowering drugs. These improvements can be seen at all stages of the disease. There are recognized interactions between glucose‐lowering drugs and physical activity which may not be synergistic, but these are not well understood, and it is not clear if they are considered in clinical practice. Studies that explicitly compare drugs with diet or physical activity or control for drug use found that lifestyle could delay or reduce medication use, but most people eventually needed to progress to drug treatment. There are few studies, however, that provide strategies for the long‐term maintenance of weight loss or physical activity. Conclusion Diet and physical activity are of key importance in type 2 diabetes management, and attention to them improves glycaemic control and cardiovascular disease risk, but it is not yet known whether maintained lifestyle changes provide an alternative to drug therapy in the long term. What's new? Interactions between physical activity and glucose‐lowering medications have been observed but are not well understood, and there is little research into the interactions between medication and overall diet patterns. Few interventions compare lifestyle with drug therapy or a control for medication use. At present available evidence indicates that most people will eventually need drug therapy in addition to lifestyle. There is little evidence for how best to support people in maintaining weight loss or physical activity for the long term. Improving maintenance strategies may help more people delay or prevent medication use.