Indigenous fire ecologies, restoration, and territorial sovereignty in the Brazilian Cerrado: The case of two Xavante reserves

• Published in: Land use policy 2021-05, Vol.104, p.104055, Article 104055
• Main Authors: Welch, James R., Coimbra Jr, Carlos E.A.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Anthropogenic fire; Appropriation; Burning; Criticism; Ethnic groups; Federal government; Fire ecology; Historical ecology; Human rights; Hunting; Indigenous peoples; Land use; Local communities; Management; Minority & ethnic groups; Project management; Public sphere; Reforestation; Reserves; Resource availability; Restoration; Sovereignty; Territorial sovereignty; Traditions; Vegetation
• ISSN: 0264-8377; 1873-5754
• DOI: 10.1016/j.landusepol.2019.104055

•In the media, Pimentel Barbosa exemplifies responsible fire management while Marãiwatsédé is emblematic of fire as crisis.•Markedly different fire profiles are attributable to divergent histories of land appropriation and use.•Cultural shaming can transfer blame for wildfires to Indigenous recuperation of territorial and cultural rights.•Conservation and restoration begin with territorial sovereignty and incorporating Indigenous communities as equal partners.•Fire ecology will benefit from culturally distinct forms of expertise on preventing and combating wildfires. Indigenous and traditional peoples worldwide ignite vegetation to promote resource availability, diversity, and resilience. Their burning traditions are indispensable for sustenance, territorial management, and cultural expression. In some countries, Indigenous peoples are key partners in developing fire policies and interventions. The Brazilian federal government has recently undertaken pilot fire management projects with Indigenous participation, receiving praise for promising early results along with cautious criticism for inadequately incorporating local communities and perspectives. The Xavante ethnic group is well known for burning cerrado vegetation during large group hunts associated with ceremonial events. Despite growing academic and policy attention to Xavante burning practices, they continue to be leveraged for cultural shaming in the public sphere. In this article, we examine interconnections between human rights and fire ecologies, management, and restoration based on the case of two Xavante Indigenous reserves in Central Brazil. Whereas the Pimentel Barbosa reserve shows evidence of reforestation in conjunction with periodic hunting with fire, Marãiwatsédé has suffered a series of highly destructive uncontrolled fires since its recent Indigenous reoccupation after decades of management by commercial ranchers. These contrasting fire profiles are largely attributable to divergent histories of land appropriation and use, suggesting that effective fire control efforts should begin with territorial sovereignty and incorporate Indigenous and traditional communities as equal conservation partners.