Temporal Stability Analysis for the Evaluation of Spatial and Temporal Patterns of Surface Water Quality

• Published in: Water resources management 2022-03, Vol.36 (4), p.1413-1429
• Main Authors: Zhang, Xiaobin, Ma, Ligang, Zhu, Yihang, Lou, Weidong, Xie, Baoliang, Sheng, Li, Hu, Hao, Zheng, Kefeng, Gu, Qing
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Agricultural land; Ammonia; Atmospheric Sciences; Civil Engineering; Correlation analysis; Dissolved oxygen; Earth and Environmental Science; Earth Sciences; Economics; Environment; Error analysis; Geotechnical Engineering & Applied Earth Sciences; Hydrogeology; Hydrology/Water Resources; Indicators; Land use; Monitoring; Monitoring systems; Nitrogen; Phosphorus; Population density; Resource management; Root-mean-square errors; Socioeconomic aspects; Spatial variations; Stability; Stability analysis; Surface stability; Surface water; Water monitoring; Water quality; Water quality management; Water quality measurements; Water resources; Water resources management
• ISSN: 0920-4741; 1573-1650
• DOI: 10.1007/s11269-022-03090-8

Better characterizing the spatio-temporal pattern of water quality would increase the ability to effectively manage water resources. This study applied the concept of temporal stability analysis (TSA) to explore the temporal characteristics of spatial variability in surface water quality. Measurement data from 41 monitoring stations in Qiantang River, China during 2017–2019 were used for analysis. The data included four water quality indicators: dissolved oxygen (DO), permanganate index (COD Mn ), total phosphorus (TP), and ammonia nitrogen (NH 3 –N). A Spearman’s rank correlation for each pair of monitoring times was performed to characterize the spatial pattern of water quality. A temporal analysis of relative differences was applied to examine the temporal stability of the sampling sites. The rank correlation analysis suggests that the spatial pattern of water quality was maintained for a specific period of time and the TP concentration was most temporally stable compared with the other three indicators across the study area. The standard deviation of the relative difference (SDRD) and index of temporal stability (ITS) were found to be better for identifying the stable sites compared to the mean absolute bias error (MABE) and root mean square error (RMSE) in this study. A correlation analysis between the temporal stability indices and potential influencing factors showed that land use proportions (forest, built-up land, and agricultural land), and socio-economic indicators (gross domestic product [GDP] and population density) were closely associated with the temporal stability of water quality. The results showed evidence that the TSA method was feasible and effective in identifying the temporal stability of surface water quality and optimizing the water quality monitoring program. This study’s method and findings can help improve surface water quality monitoring strategies and water resource management.