The constitution of the city and the critique of critical urban theory

• Published in: Urban studies (Edinburgh, Scotland) Scotland), 2022-05, Vol.59 (6), p.1105-1129
• Main Author: Scott, Allen J.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Cities; Division of labor; Interdependence; Postcolonialism; Theory; Urban areas; Urbanization
• ISSN: 0042-0980; 1360-063X
• DOI: 10.1177/00420980211011028

A theoretical account of the genesis and internal spatial structure of cities is given. The essence of the urbanisation process is described in terms of the following main developmental phases: (a) the emergence of relationships based on specialisation and interdependence in society; (b) the pre-eminent role of the division of labour within these relationships and its recomposition in dense spatial nodes of human activity; and (c) the concomitant formation of the networked intra-urban spaces of the city. These phases are then contextualised within three intertwined dimensions of urban materiality, namely, an internal dimension (the internal organisation and spatial dynamics of the city), a socially ambient dimension (the relational structure of society at large) and an exogenous dimension (the geographic outside of the city). In light of this account, an evaluative review of what I designate ‘the new critical urban theory’ is carried out, with special reference to planetary urbanisation, postcolonial urban theory and comparativist methodologies. I argue that while every individual city represents a uniquely complex combination of social conjunctures, there are nonetheless definite senses in which urban phenomena are susceptible to investigation at the highest levels of theoretical generality.