Revisiting the Precipitous Terrain Classification from a Meteorological Perspective

• Published in: Journal of applied meteorology and climatology 2021-10, Vol.60 (10), p.1387-1406
• Main Authors: Muñoz-Esparza, Domingo, Shin, Hyeyum Hailey, Keller, Teddie L., Ikeda, Kyoko, Sharman, Robert D., Steiner, Matthias, Rawdon, Jeff, Pokodner, Gary
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Aircraft accidents & safety; Aircraft landing; Airports; Algorithms; Altimeters; Altitude; Altitude effects; Aviation; Classification; Cold season; Control equipment; Density; Errors; High resolution; Instrument approach; Low level turbulence; Maneuvers; Mountains; Resolution; Terrain; Topography; Turbulence; Weather forecasting
• ISSN: 1558-8424; 1558-8432
• DOI: 10.1175/JAMC-D-20-0268.1

Takeoff and landing maneuvers can be particularly hazardous at airports surrounded by complex terrain. To address this situation, the Federal Aviation Administration has developed a precipitous terrain classification as a way to impose more restrictive terrain clearances in the vicinity of complex terrain and to mitigate possible altimeter errors and pilot control problems experienced while executing instrument approach procedures. The current precipitous point value (PPV) algorithm relies on the terrain characteristics within a local area of 2 n mi (3.7 km) in radius and is therefore static in time. In this work, we investigate the role of meteorological effects leading to potential aviation hazards over complex terrain, namely, turbulence, altimeter-setting errors, and density-altitude deviations. To that end, we combine observations with high-resolution numerical weather forecasts within a 2° × 2° region over the Rocky Mountains in Colorado containing three airports that are surrounded by precipitous terrain. Both available turbulence reports and model’s turbulence forecasts show little correlation with the PPV algorithm for the region analyzed, indicating that the static terrain characteristics cannot generally be used to reliably capture hazardous low-level turbulence events. Altimeter-setting errors and density-altitude effects are also found to be only very weakly correlated with the PPV algorithm. Altimeter-setting errors contribute to hazardous conditions mainly during cold seasons, driven by synoptic weather systems, whereas density-altitude effects are on the contrary predominantly present during the spring and summer months and follow a very well-marked diurnal evolution modulated by surface radiative effects. These findings demonstrate the effectiveness of high-resolution weather forecast information in determining aviation-relevant hazardous conditions over complex terrain.