Watching the Clocks: Interpreting the Page–Wootters Formalism and the Internal Quantum Reference Frame Programme

• Published in: Foundations of physics 2022-10, Vol.52 (5), Article 99
• Main Author: Adlam, Emily
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Alliances; Classical and Quantum Gravitation; Classical Mechanics; Clocks; Equivalence principle; Formalism; History and Philosophical Foundations of Physics; Philosophy of Science; Physics; Physics and Astronomy; Quantum Physics; Reference systems; Relativity; Relativity Theory; Statistical Physics and Dynamical Systems
• ISSN: 0015-9018; 1572-9516
• DOI: 10.1007/s10701-022-00620-7

We discuss some difficulties that arise in attempting to interpret the Page–Wootters and Internal Quantum Reference Frames formalisms, then use a ‘final measurement’ approach to demonstrate that there is a workable single-world realist interpretation for these formalisms. We note that it is necessary to adopt some interpretation before we can determine if the ‘reference frames’ invoked in these approaches are operationally meaningful, and we argue that without a clear operational interpretation, such reference frames might not be suitable to define an equivalence principle. We argue that the notion of superposition should take into account the way in which an instantaneous state is embedded in ongoing dynamical evolution, and this leads to a more nuanced way of thinking about the relativity of superposition in these approaches. We conclude that typically the operational content of these approaches appears only in the limit as the size of at least one reference system becomes large, and therefore these formalisms have an important role to play in showing how our macroscopic reference frames can emerge out of wholly relational facts.