Formation of reference groups for archaeological pottery using neutron activation and multivariate statistical analyses

• Published in: Archaeometry 2022-12, Vol.64 (6), p.1377-1393
• Main Authors: Badawy, Wael M., Dmitriev, Andrey Yu, Koval, Vladimir Yu, Smirnova, Veronica S., Chepurchenko, Olesia E., Lobachev, Valery V., Belova, Maria O., Galushko, Aleksey M.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: archaeological ceramics; Archaeology; Ceramics; Chemical composition; Chromium; elemental composition; fingerprints; Historic artifacts; INAA; multivariate analysis; Neutrons; Statistical analysis
• ISSN: 0003-813X; 1475-4754
• DOI: 10.1111/arcm.12793

For the first time in Russia, instrumental neutron activation analysis (INAA) and related analytical techniques were used to determine the distribution patterns of elemental composition in archeological pottery in terms of classification and provenance of medieval pottery. A total of 48 fragments have been discovered in three locations; Bolgar, the Moscow Kremlin (MosKremlin), and Selitrennoe settlement (Selitrennoe). The assemblages were subjected to INAA in order to determine the concentrations of 37 elements in mg/kg. The data were analyzed using geochemical, bivariate, and multivariate statistical techniques. To classify the fragments according to their origin hierarchical clustering (HCA), linear discriminant (LDA), and principal component analyses (PCA) were used. Based on the INAA results, the first attempt was made to apply machine learning methods to the study of artifacts in Russia. The results show that they are reliable and powerful in extracting information about critical elements for identifying ceramic fragments and using them as chemical fingerprints. Chromium was the most useful element and was used in conjunction with other elements as a fingerprint to distinguish sherds. Chemical and statistical analyses help to establish of reference groups for medieval archeological pottery, which will be used in the future to classify and identify various unknown sherds. These reference groups serve as baseline data for determining the fragment's place of manufacture and are considered a reasonable judgment based on experimental data.