Exploring the impact of economic integration agreements through extreme bounds analysis

• Published in: Review of international economics 2023-02, Vol.31 (1), p.35-59
• Main Authors: Park, Byungyul, Beghin, John
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Agreements; Candidates; Economic integration; economic integration agreements; extreme bounds analysis; Free trade; Gravity; gravity equation; Trade agreements; Trade flows
• ISSN: 0965-7576; 1467-9396
• DOI: 10.1111/roie.12610

This article provides an empirical strategy guided by the data to estimate the effects of Economic Integration Agreements (EIAs) on trade flows and their transitional dynamics. The strategy uses Extreme Bounds Analysis (EBA) to guide the choice of lags and leads in the effects without researchers' discretion involved. We show that arbitrarily selected year intervals and starting year can result in non‐robust estimates of transitional dynamics of the effects of EIAs on trade flows. The empirical strategy follows two steps: EBA first sifts lags and leads of EIAs robustly related to trade flows from candidates, then these are included in the gravity equation to estimate the effects of EIAs on trade. We find that various lags and leads are robustly and positively related to trade flows, and the lag and lead structure depends on the level of integration. Our results show that EIAs have a long‐term effect of 63% on trade flows. Under the richer lag and lead structure, deep‐integration agreements beyond the level of free trade agreements have a much higher impact on trade flows than free trade agreements do (132% vs 31%). The estimates of effects of EIAs obtained from EBA‐based estimation have a smaller contemporaneous effect and larger phased‐in effects compared to previous studies relying on the subjective choices of year intervals while similar results are observed with the decomposed EIAs.