Indicators of soil quality and crop productivity assessment at a long‐term experiment site in the lower Indo‐Gangetic plains

• Published in: Soil use and management 2023-01, Vol.39 (1), p.503-520
• Main Authors: Ghorai, Partha Sarathi, Biswas, Sunanda, Purakayastha, Tapan Jyoti, Ahmed, Nayan, Das, Tapas Kumar, Prasanna, Radha, Gawade, Bharat Hanamant, Bhattacharyya, Kallol, Sinha, Kanchan, Singh, Priya, Das, Sujit
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Amidase; Animal manures; Biofertilizers; Calcium chloride; Cereal crops; Climate change; conceptual framework; Crop production; Crop yield; Cropping systems; Data reduction; Environmental protection; equivalent rice yield; expert opinion; Farms; Fertilizers; Food security; Global climate; Glucosidase; Indicators; Mustard; Oilseed crops; Organic carbon; PCA; Potassium permanganate; Principal components analysis; Productivity; Quality assessment; Quality control; Regional development; Regression analysis; Rice; Soil; Soil degradation; Soil quality; Soil surfaces; Soils; Statistical analysis; Total organic carbon; Urease
• ISSN: 0266-0032; 1475-2743
• DOI: 10.1111/sum.12847

Deterioration of soil quality under resource‐intensive modern agriculture in the face of global climate change poses a huge risk to food security. Because of the complex nature, estimators of soil quality often rely upon a limited set of soil attributes, along with statistical data reduction techniques, for developing quality indices, whilst overlooking biological aspects and regional climatic variability. This study screened the most suitable soil quality indexing approaches for a rice‐oilseed‐based cropping system in the lower Indo‐Gangetic plains (IGP). For this, surface soil samples (0–15 cm) were collected from an ongoing long‐term fertilizer experiment with a rice‐mustard‐sesame cropping system in the IGP. The following treatments were assessed for their effect on soil quality: T1‐control, T2‐NPK (recommended NPK doses), T3‐NPKG (NPK + in situ green manuring), T4‐NPKGB (NPK + in situ green manuring + biofertilizer) and T5‐NPKF (NPK + farm yard manure FYM). We found that total organic carbon (TOC), β‐glucosidase, CaCl2 extractable S, alkaline KMnO4 oxidizable N, activity of urease, amidase enzyme and mean weight diameter (MWD) were sensitive key indicators of soil quality. The NPKF treatment maintained the highest soil quality status (0.80–0.91), both under productivity and environmental protection goals, owing to the availability of decomposable carbon. Regression analysis showed a better agreement of equivalent rice yield with expert opinion (EO; R2 = 0.89) than principal component analysis (PCA; R2 = 0.76). Finally, we found that the expert opinion approach with the nonlinear scoring function was the best tool for soil quality assessment of the region.