The Thermosphere Is a Drag: The 2022 Starlink Incident and the Threat of Geomagnetic Storms to Low Earth Orbit Space Operations

• Published in: Space Weather 2023-03, Vol.21 (3), p.n/a
• Main Authors: Berger, T. E., Dominique, M., Lucas, G., Pilinski, M., Ray, V., Sewell, R., Sutton, E. K., Thayer, J. P., Thiemann, E.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Accelerometers; Altitude; Atmosphere; Atmospheric density; Atmospheric drag; Atmospheric entry; Atmospheric models; Controllers; Drag; Earth orbits; Empirical models; Errors; Extreme weather; Geomagnetic storms; Geomagnetism; ionosphere; Low earth orbits; Magnetic storms; Magnetospheres; Modelling; Nowcasting; Operators; Satellite constellations; satellite drag; Satellite tracking; Satellites; Sea level; Solar EUV; Space weather; Storms; Thermosphere; Traffic control; Traffic management; Upper atmosphere
• ISSN: 1542-7390; 1539-4964; 1542-7390
• DOI: 10.1029/2022SW003330

On 03 February 2022, SpaceX launched 49 Starlink satellites, 38 of which re‐entered the atmosphere on or about 07 February 2022 due to unexpectedly high atmospheric drag. We use empirical model (NRLMSIS, JB08, and HASDM) outputs as well as solar extreme ultraviolet occultation and high‐fidelity accelerometer data to show that thermospheric density was at least 20%–30% higher at 210 km relative to the 9 days prior to the launch due to consecutive geomagnetic storms related to solar eruptions from NOAA AR12936 on 29 January 2022. We model the orbital altitude and in‐track position of a Starlink‐like satellite in a low‐drag configuration at 200 km during minor (G1) and extreme (G5) geomagnetic storms to show that an extreme storm would have at least a factor of two higher impact, with cumulative in‐track errors on the order of 10,000 km after a 5‐day duration extreme storm. Comparison of the JB08 and NRL MSIS models relative to the HASDM model during modeled historical minor and extreme geomagnetic storms shows that in‐track errors on the order of 100 km per day at 250 km, decreasing to cumulative errors on the order of 1 km per day at 550 km during geomagnetic storms. We conclude that full‐physics, data assimilative, coupled models of the magnetosphere and upper atmosphere, as well as new operational satellite missions providing “nowcasting” data to launch controllers, space traffic coordinators, and satellite operators, are needed to prevent similar—or worse—orbital system impacts during future geomagnetic storms. Plain Language Summary On 03 February 2022, SpaceX launched 49 Starlink satellites into staging orbits at 210 km above sea level prior to raising them to their operational altitudes of 550 km. The pre‐launch space weather briefing included no information about an ongoing geomagnetic storm. Excessive atmospheric drag due to the geomagnetic storm resulted in 38 of the satellites re‐entering the atmosphere on or about 07 February 2022. We use both models and direct measurements of the atmospheric density during the event to show that density values were enhanced by 20%–30% at the 210 km staging altitude relative to values prior to the geomagnetic storm onset, while they were enhanced 90%–160% at higher altitudes. We recommend improving our ability to model the upper atmospheric response to geomagnetic storms to provide accurate forecasts and actionable “nowcasts” of conditions in low Earth orbit to launch controllers, space traffic managers, and sate