Measuring geomorphology in river assessment procedures 1: A global overview of current practices

• Published in: Journal of the American Water Resources Association 2023-12, Vol.59 (6), p.1342-1359
• Main Authors: Papangelakis, Elli, Hassan, Marwan A., Luzi, David, Burge, Leif M., Peirce, Sarah
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Assessments; geomorphic indicators; Geomorphology; Habitats; Indicators; Project management; river assessment; river management; Rivers; Sediment transport; stream assessment
• ISSN: 1093-474X; 1752-1688
• DOI: 10.1111/1752-1688.13146

Despite geomorphic processes being increasingly recognized as a vital component of river management projects, evidence suggests that they may not be adequately captured in common river assessment procedures. We reviewed 91 river assessment procedures from around the world to evaluate their effectiveness in capturing geomorphic processes relevant for river management goals. Our objectives were to summarize which common geomorphic indicators are measured and how in different types of river assessments categorized based on their main focus: geomorphic, physical habitat, mixed geomorphic and habitat, and hydromorphology. Our analysis identified differences in the types of geomorphic indicators included and measurement methodologies between the types of assessment procedures. Some geomorphic processes, such as sediment transport, are nearly completely absent from all assessments, despite their importance for geomorphic processes. The variability among assessment procedures suggests that a single procedure is unlikely to capture all geomorphic components required to support every river management programs. Here, we discuss how the strengths and limitations of different assessment types can be used to guide decisions around how to select assessments and geomorphic indicators to support management project goals. A companion paper expands the discussion of how to plan effective river assessment procedures to support unique management goals.