Analyzing and Debugging Normative Requirements via Satisfiability Checking

• Published in: arXiv.org 2024-01
• Main Authors: Feng, Nick, Marsso, Lina, Yaman, Sinem Getir, Baatartogtokh, Yesugen, Ayad, Reem, Victória Oldemburgo de Mello, Townsend, Beverley, Standen, Isobel, Stefanakos, Ioannis, Imrie, Calum, Genaína Nunes Rodrigues, Cavalcanti, Ana, Calinescu, Radu, Chechik, Marsha
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Debugging; End users; Ethical standards; Redundancy; Robots; Software
• ISSN: 2331-8422
• DOI: 10.48550/arxiv.2401.05673

As software systems increasingly interact with humans in application domains such as transportation and healthcare, they raise concerns related to the social, legal, ethical, empathetic, and cultural (SLEEC) norms and values of their stakeholders. Normative non-functional requirements (N-NFRs) are used to capture these concerns by setting SLEEC-relevant boundaries for system behavior. Since N-NFRs need to be specified by multiple stakeholders with widely different, non-technical expertise (ethicists, lawyers, regulators, end users, etc.), N-NFR elicitation is very challenging. To address this challenge, we introduce N-Check, a novel tool-supported formal approach to N-NFR analysis and debugging. N-Check employs satisfiability checking to identify a broad spectrum of N-NFR well-formedness issues (WFI), such as conflicts, redundancy, restrictiveness, insufficiency, yielding diagnostics which pinpoint their causes in a user-friendly way that enables non-technical stakeholders to understand and fix them. We show the effectiveness and usability of our approach through nine case studies in which teams of ethicists, lawyers, philosophers, psychologists, safety analysts, and engineers used N-Check to analyse and debug 233 N-NFRs comprising 62 issues for the software underpinning the operation of systems ranging from assistive-care robots and tree-disease detection drones to manufacturing collaborative robots.