Plant and microbial feedbacks maintain soil nitrogen legacies in burned and unburned grasslands

• Published in: The Journal of ecology 2024-09, Vol.112 (9), p.2093-2106
• Main Authors: Nieland, Matthew A., Zeglin, Lydia H.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: above‐ground net primary productivity; Air quality; Ammonium nitrate; Availability; Controlled burning; Denitrification; Dominant species; Ecological function; ecological memory; Ecosystem management; Ecosystem recovery; Ecosystem structure; Ecosystems; Eutrophication; Fertilization; fire; Fires; Functionals; Grasses; Grasslands; Historical structures; legacy; Microorganisms; Nitrification; Nitrogen; Plant production; Plants; Prairies; Prescribed fire; Recovering; Recovery of function; Soil pollution; Soil properties; Soil structure; Structure-function relationships; tallgrass prairie
• ISSN: 0022-0477; 1365-2745
• DOI: 10.1111/1365-2745.14386

Nitrogen (N) availability is a well‐known driver of ecosystem structure and function, but as air quality regulations continue to reduce atmospheric N deposition, there is a need to understand how managed and unmanaged ecosystems respond to widespread decreases in terrestrial N availability. Historical N eutrophication, from pollution or fertilisation, may continue to constrain contemporary responses to decreases in available N because of altered plant and microbial feedbacks. Thus, while certain management practices like prescribed fire remove N from grassland ecosystems, the role of fire supporting ecosystems recovering from chronic N input is unknown. To address this knowledge gap, we ceased a 30‐year N‐fertilisation treatment at a field experiment in a tallgrass prairie ecosystem crossed with burned and fire‐suppressed (unburned) treatments. We established subplots within each previously fertilised, recovering plot, fertilised at the same historical rate (10 g N m−2 year−1 as NH4NO3), to compare plant and soil properties in recovering plots with control (never‐fertilised) and still‐fertilised treatments within different fire regimes. We document different N‐fertilisation legacies among ecosystem properties in burned and unburned prairies recovering from N‐fertilisation. Soil N availability, nitrification and denitrification potentials in recovering plots remained higher than controls for 3–5 years—indicative of positive legacies—in both burned and unburned prairies, but burning did not reduce this legacy. In burned prairies, however, a positive legacy in above‐ground plant production persisted because a more productive grass species (switchgrass) replaced the previously dominant species (big bluestem) even though root C:N, but not soil C:N, increased to return back to control levels. Consequently, the main N loss pathways in burned and unburned prairies (pyrovolatilisation and microbially mediated processes, respectively) led to similar losses of soil total N (20–28 g N m−2) over 5 years. Synthesis: Our results indicate that N eutrophication induces positive legacies of ecosystem functions that can persist for at least half a decade. N‐induced legacies arise because of shifts in soil microbial N‐cycling and plant functional traits. As a result, different management practices may elicit similar trajectories of ecosystem recovery in terms of total and available soil N because of different plant and microbial feedbacks. At a tallgrass prairie experiment cr