The Use of Phosphonates to Inhibit Salt Crystallization: A Laboratory Study for the Sustainable Conservation of Mural Paintings in the Hypogea Context

• Published in: Sustainability 2024-11, Vol.16 (22), p.9745
• Main Authors: Simonelli, Giulia, Sidoti, Giancarlo, Ruggiero, Ludovica, Calia, Angela, Quarta, Giovanni, Aramini, Fabio, Mezzadri, Paola
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Adsorption; Control; Crystallization; Environmental sustainability; Habitus; Humidity; Hydrogen bonds; Management; Mural painting and decoration; Phosphonates; Porous materials; Potassium; Protection and preservation; Salt; Sodium; Stone; Testing laboratories
• ISSN: 2071-1050; 2071-1050
• DOI: 10.3390/su16229745

This research is focused on the laboratory study of salt crystallization inhibitor products as new materials for conservation treatments which can be applied to mortars and painted plasters; as is well known, salt crystallization is one of the most frequent causes of decay processes on decorated architectural surfaces in a wide range of environments. Specifically, the study targets the field of the preventive conservation of mural paintings within rupestrian heritage sites. For the first time, systematic investigations were performed on mock-ups made of plaster painted with two different pigments: yellow ochre and carbon black. Two types of phosphonate inhibitors, PBTC (2-phosphonobutane-1,2,4-tricarboxylic acid) and ATMP (aminotris (methylene phosphonic acid)), were chosen and applied at two different concentrations. Given the limited literature available, and the presence of pigments potentially sensitive to treatment with salt inhibitors, preliminary tests were required. Their effects on the chromatic features of the pigments were evaluated visually and using colorimetry. The changes in the behaviour of water circulation in the mortar resulting from the treatments were evaluated through water vapour permeability and absorption tests. Accelerated crystallization experiments were carried out to assess how inhibitors could influence the growth of salts and the resulting material damage. The latter was carried out by employing sodium sulphate and calcium sulphate solutions, quantifying the damage to the specimens through material loss in weight and the percentage of painted surface loss. Based on the overall results, the product with the best performance was identified was ATMP 0.1% (by volume) in deionized water. The obtained results show that salt inhibitor treatments are promising for in situ application and could represent an innovative approach to promote the sustainable conservation of mural painting, particularly those located in hypogeal contexts, where the salt supply cannot be removed and slowing the growth of salts and/or changing their crystalline habitus may be effective in limiting their damage.