Measuring the crime displacement and diffusion of benefit effects of open-street CCTV in South Korea

• Published in: International journal of law, crime and justice crime and justice, 2012-09, Vol.40 (3), p.179-191
• Main Authors: Park, Hyeon Ho, Oh, Gyeong Seok, Paek, Seung Yeop
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: CCTV (Closed-circuit Television); Controversy; Crime; Crime displacement; Crime Prevention; Criminal sociology. Police. Delinquency. Deviance. Suicide; Diffusion of benefit; Diffusionism; Displacement; Marginal utility; Neighbourhoods; Sociology; Sociology of law and criminology; South Korea; Television; Violence; WDQ (Weighted Displacement Quotient)
• ISSN: 1756-0616; 1876-763X
• DOI: 10.1016/j.ijlcj.2012.03.003

Crime prevention strategies are implemented to reduce the damage caused by crimes with CCTV (Closed-Circuit Television) being broadly accepted as one of the main strategies. However, along with CCTV's perceived high expectations as crime deterrent, there is also a growing controversy over CCTV's potentially unexpected limitations. For example, the crime displacement (the presence of CCTV will change the locations of crime and its total number will not change) and the diffusion effects of crime control benefits (the crime prevention effect of CCTV may filter through to neighboring areas) are the representative controversial issues. In this study, we aimed to verify the crime displacement and the diffusion of benefit of open-street CCTV by analyzing the crime tendencies empirically. Gwang Myeong City in Gyeonggi Province, South Korea was chosen to analyze the crime displacement using the WDQ (Weighted Displacement Quotient) which compares the crime tendency of a location with that of its neighboring areas. The results showed that the crime prevention effect of the CCTV was significant. The number of robberies and thefts in the areas with CCTV installed reduced by 47.4%, while the areas without CCTV showed practically no change in the number of crimes. The crime displacement caused by the CCTV was not either found or inconsequential, and the crime rates in the neighboring areas also decreased slightly. Of major cause for concern was the fact that CCTV was marginally effective in deterring violence and as such, there should be a more detailed scientific analysis of the pattern and type of crimes committed in an area where CCTV's are being installed.