Peer assessment among first year medical students in anatomy

• Published in: Anatomical sciences education 2014-03, Vol.7 (2), p.144-152
• Main Authors: Spandorfer, John, Puklus, Tanya, Rose, Victoria, Vahedi, Mithaq, Collins, Lauren, Giordano, Carolyn, Schmidt, Richard, Braster, Chris
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Adult; Anatomy; Anatomy - education; assessment; Attitude Measures; Cohort Analysis; Communication; Course Evaluation; Data Analysis; Educational Measurement - methods; Feedback (Response); formative feedback; gross anatomy education; Humans; Interpersonal Competence; Interpersonal Relations; medical education; Medical Students; Mixed Methods Research; Online Surveys; Peer Evaluation; Peer Group; peer-assessment; Professional Competence; professionalism; Scores; Student Attitudes; Student Improvement; Students, Medical; summative feedback; Test Taking Skills
• ISSN: 1935-9772; 1935-9780
• DOI: 10.1002/ase.1394

Peer assessment has been shown to be an effective tool to promote professionalism in medical students. Peer assessment may be particularly useful in anatomy dissection laboratory as the required close collaboration and long hours of anatomy laboratory provide students insights into their peers' work habits and interpersonal skills. The objective of this study was to quantitatively and qualitatively analyze the use of a validated peer assessment tool in Gross Anatomy. Students in a first year medical school class evaluated three members of their dissection group using an online survey tool. The mid‐course and end‐of‐course evaluation included open‐ended comments, as well as a five‐point scale that measured three work habits, two interpersonal attributes and one overall score. All 267 students completed the assignment. The overall score and four of the five other assessed categories showed significant improvement from the mid‐ to end‐of‐course evaluations. Quantitative and qualitative data also revealed significant improvement among the students who received the lowest mid‐course assessments. Seventy‐six percent of the class agreed with the statement: “Based on the feedback I received, I made a change in how I worked with or taught my peers.” The use of this peer assessment tool used by students in anatomy was associated with improvements in work habits and interpersonal attributes, particularly by the cohort of students who received the lowest mid‐course feedback. Peer assessment offers students an opportunity to improve their interpersonal skills and work habits. Anat Sci Educ 7: 144–152. © 2013 American Association of Anatomists.