Motivation in software engineering industrial practice: A cross-case analysis of two software organisations

• Published in: Information and software technology 2014-01, Vol.56 (1), p.79-101
• Main Authors: França, A. César C., da Silva, Fabio Q.B., Felix, Adelnei de L.C., Carneiro, David E.S.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Case studies; Computer programs; Meta-ethnography; Motivation; Multi-case replication design; Qualitative research; Software; Software engineer; Software engineering; Software industry; Studies
• ISSN: 0950-5849; 1873-6025
• DOI: 10.1016/j.infsof.2013.06.006

The research about motivation in software engineering has provided important insights into characterizing factors and outcomes related to motivation. However, the complex relationships among these factors, including the moderating and mediating effects of organisational and individual characteristics, still require deeper explanatory investigation. Our general goal is to build explanatory theories of motivation in different software organisations and to integrate these local theories towards a comprehensive understanding of the role of motivation in the effectiveness of the individuals and the teams in which they work. In this article, we describe the integrative synthesis of the results of two case studies performed with software organisations in different business contexts. We performed two case studies using a multiple-case, replication design, focusing on the software engineers as the unit of analysis. For 13months, we conducted semi structured interviews, diary studies, and document analyses, and analysed the collected data using grounded theory procedures. The results of the two cases were synthesized using a meta-ethnography supported process. We built translations of the concepts and propositions from the two studies into one another. We then used the translations to build a central story of motivation that synthesizes the individual stories. This synthesis is contextualized by the differences in organisational and individual characteristics. The differences in organisational contexts and in the characteristics of the software engineers in each study provided rich explanations for contrasts in perceptions and feelings about motivation in both organisations. The theory that emerged from the synthesis, supported by these explanations, provides a deeper understanding of the interplay between motivators and outcomes, and the needs and personal goals of the software engineers. This theory also characterises the role of team cohesion in motivation, advancing previous models about motivation in software engineering.