“Do the right thing:” The effects of moral suasion on cooperation

• Published in: Journal of public economics 2014-09, Vol.117, p.28-38
• Main Authors: Dal Bó, Ernesto, Dal Bó, Pedro
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Cooperation; Ethics; Moral suasion; Morality; Morals; Public goods; Punishment; Utilitarianism
• ISSN: 0047-2727; 1879-2316
• DOI: 10.1016/j.jpubeco.2014.05.002

The use of moral appeals to affect the behavior of others is pervasive (from the pulpit to ethics classes) but little is known about the effects of moral suasion on behavior. In a series of experiments we study whether moral suasion affects behavior in voluntary contribution games and the mechanisms by which behavior is altered. We find that observing a message with a moral standard according to the golden rule or, alternatively, utilitarian philosophy, results in a significant but transitory increase in contributions above the levels observed for subjects that did not receive a message or received a message that advised them to contribute without a moral rationale. When players have the option of punishing each other after the contribution stage, the effect of the moral messages on contributions becomes persistent: punishments and moral messages interact to sustain cooperation. We also investigate the mechanisms through which moral suasion operates and find that it affects both expectations and preferences. •We study whether moral suasion affects behavior in a series of voluntary contribution games experiment.•Moral suasion has a significant but transitory effect.•Moral suasion has a persistent effect when a punishment stage is available after the contribution stage of the voluntary contribution experiment.•Moral suasion operates by affecting both preferences and expectations about others.