Fishers' perceptions, facilitating factors and challenges of community-based no-take zones in the Sian Ka’an Biosphere Reserve, Quintana Roo, Mexico

• Published in: Marine policy 2014-03, Vol.45, p.171-181
• Main Authors: Velez, Mariana, Adlerstein, Sara, Wondolleck, Julia
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Artisanal lobster fishery; Biosphere; Caribbean; Collaborative resource management; Community-based management; Conservation; Design engineering; Difference; Dynamics; Economics; Environmental degradation; Fisheries; Fishers' perceptions; Leadership; Marine protected areas; Mexico; No-take zones; Panulirus argus; Perception; Pontophilus spinosus; Reserves; Responsibility; Sustainability
• ISSN: 0308-597X; 1872-9460
• DOI: 10.1016/j.marpol.2013.12.003

In response to fisheries decline in the Mexican Caribbean and continuing deterioration of the Mesoamerican Reef, conservation NGOs have begun to negotiate and collaboratively design a network of no-take zones (NTZs) with three fishing cooperatives in the Sian Ka’an Biosphere Reserve (SKBR), among other places along the coast of Quintana Roo. Spiny lobster (Panulirus argus) is the target of the main fishery within cooperative concessions. Fishers are uniquely positioned to enforce and monitor NTZs and evaluate their effectiveness. This study analyzes fishers' perceptions as indicators of social acceptance of NTZs, and identifies facilitating factors and challenges of the community-based process. Consistent with similar studies, responses of fishers (89 out of a population of 124) to a semi-structured interview showed that perceptions of NTZs largely reflect fishers' concerns and interests. A high proportion of fishers accurately identified main NTZ objectives of regulation, conservation and economic improvement, as well as NTZ locations. Further, fishers cared about ecosystem sustainability and, because NTZs would not significantly limit their main economic activity, endorsed the initiative while expecting additional benefits. Declining trends in lobster catch influenced a perceived need for NTZs. Major concerns were that illegal fishers would reap NTZ benefits and that economic impacts and benefits were uncertain. Most fishers found the decision-making process inclusive, were willing to take responsibility for enforcing NTZs and believed people leading the process were trustworthy. Differences in endorsement of NTZs among cooperatives points to the importance of understanding fishers’ incentives to collaborate, and the leadership and organizational dynamics which shape participatory processes. This analysis highlights challenges in advancing NTZs in complex ecological, socio-economic and regulatory contexts. It underscores the need for community-based processes that transcend understanding of conservation measures but also invests in sustainable, operative and trustful working relationships, as well as the urgency of interdisciplinary approaches in ensuring effective design and implementation of this relatively new fishery management tool. •Fishers and scientists collaboratively designed a system of NTZs.•Fishers' concern for ecosystem sustainability prompted engagement in NTZ selection.•Resistance was rooted in uncertain outcomes and fear that others woul