Teaching Citizens: The Role of Open Classroom Climate in Fostering Critical Consciousness Among Youth

• Published in: Journal of youth and adolescence 2014-11, Vol.43 (11), p.1801-1817
• Main Authors: Godfrey, Erin B., Grayman, Justina Kamiel
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Adolescent; Adolescent Behavior; Adolescents; Behavioral Science and Psychology; Career development planning; Child and School Psychology; Child development; Citizen participation; Citizens; Citizenship; Classroom Environment; Classrooms; Climate; Clinical Psychology; Cognitive Development; Community; Consciousness; Cultural Competency; Educational Policy; Educational Practices; Effectiveness; Empirical Research; Empowerment; Female; Health Psychology; History of Psychology; Humans; Law and Psychology; Majorities; Male; Mental health; Minority & ethnic groups; Minority Groups; Participation; Politics; Prediction; Psychology; Racial Differences; School environment; Schools; Self Efficacy; Social conditions & trends; Social Responsibility; Social Support; Society; Sociopolitical factors; Students; Students - statistics & numerical data; Teaching - methods; United States; Whites; Youth
• ISSN: 0047-2891; 1573-6601
• DOI: 10.1007/s10964-013-0084-5

Building on previous research on critical consciousness and civic development among youth, the current study examined the extent to which an open climate for discussion—one in which controversial issues are openly discussed with respect for all opinions—relates to youth’s critical consciousness and whether this association differs for youth from racial/ethnic majority versus minority backgrounds. Critical consciousness consisted of three components: the ability to critically read social conditions (critical reflection), feelings of efficacy to effect change (sociopolitical efficacy) and actual participation in these efforts (critical action), in both the educational and political/community domains. Open classroom climate was operationalized at the classroom rather than individual student level to more accurately draw links to educational policy and practice. Multilevel analyses of the 1999 IEA Civic Education Study, a nationally-representative sample of 2,774 US ninth-graders (50 % female; 58 % white), revealed that an open classroom climate predicted some, but not all, components of critical consciousness. Specifically, open classroom climate was positively related to sociopolitical efficacy in both the educational and political domains and to critical action in the community domain, but was not related to critical reflection. Few differences in these associations were found for youth from racial/ethnic majority versus minority backgrounds. The exception was sociopolitical efficacy in the educational domain: open classroom climate was particularly predictive of sociopolitical efficacy for minority youth. The findings are discussed in regard to previous research on open classroom climate and youth critical consciousness; and implications for future research and educational practice are drawn.