The role of entrepreneurial decision-making in opportunity creation and recognition

• Published in: Technovation 2015-05, Vol.39-40 (39-40), p.53-72
• Main Authors: Maine, Elicia, Soh, Pek-Hooi, Dos Santos, Nancy
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Biotechnology; Biotechnology industry; Canada; Causality; Causation; Cause & effect diagrams; Commercialization; Decision making; Decision making models; Effectuation; Entrepreneurial decision-making; Entrepreneurs; Entrepreneurship; Funding; Inventions; Opportunity; Opportunity creation; Opportunity recognition; Pharmaceutical industry; Platforms; Recognition; Risk perception; Scientist-entrepreneurs; Studies; U.S.A; Uncertainty
• ISSN: 0166-4972; 1879-2383
• DOI: 10.1016/j.technovation.2014.02.007

This qualitative study investigates effectuation and causation as two opposing decisionmaking modes leading to opportunity creation and recognition. Prior literature posits that effectuation is linked to opportunity creation when the venture׳s future is highly uncertain and causation to opportunity recognition when the entrepreneur perceives risk rather than uncertainty. However, such a linear approach towards opportunity generation offers limited explanation as to how entrepreneurs decide to either create or search for entrepreneurial opportunities. This limitation becomes particularly apparent in the highly uncertain context of the biotechnology industry, where entrepreneurial decision-making processes iterate over long periods of time. To address this gap, we employ the embedded case study method to investigate 30 decisions made by three scientist-entrepreneurs commercializing platform biotechnology inventions. We inductively derive a model of entrepreneurial decision-making, which connects the environment to decision-making mode and opportunity generation. Our evidence reveals the iterative nature of opportunity generation and of decision-making modes as entrepreneurs respond to their evolving environment and to the level of regulatory and funding constraint, such that entrepreneurs can shift from effectuation to causation, remain in one particular mode, or adopt a combination mode. We also illustrate that effectuation does not always lead to opportunity creation. •We inductively derive a model of the entrepreneurial decision-making process.•We illustrate that effectuation does not always lead to opportunity creation.•Effectuation increases resilience in highly uncertain environments.•Entrepreneurs may shift from effectuation to causation or a combination of both.•Funding and regulatory constraints act as a moderator of the decision-making process.