Management of natural resources in a conflicting environment in Ghana: unmasking a messy policy problem

• Published in: Journal of environmental planning and management 2014-11, Vol.57 (11), p.1724-1745
• Main Authors: Armah, Frederick A., Luginaah, Isaac, Yengoh, Genesis T., Taabazuing, Joseph, Yawson, David O.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Commodification; Commons; Communities; Conflict; conflict characterisation; Conflicts; Dynamical systems; Earth and Related Environmental Sciences; Economic community of West African states; Economics; Environment; Environmental policy; Farmers; Fisheries; Forestry; Geovetenskap och miljövetenskap; Ghana; governance; governance, forestry, mining; Government agencies; Infringement; Land; Land ownership; Land rights; mining; Mining industry; Natural resource management; Natural resources; Natural Sciences; Naturgeografi; Naturvetenskap; Physical Geography; Policies; Policy making; Property; Property rights; Resource management; Resource utilization; Science; Studies; systems
• ISSN: 0964-0568; 1360-0559; 1360-0559
• DOI: 10.1080/09640568.2013.834247

Resource use conflict is an enduring problem for science and policy making. Using in-depth interviews and focus group discussions with resource users, policy makers and key informants, we explored four case examples of resource use conflict within lands and forestry, fisheries, oil and the mining sectors in Ghana. Results indicate that resource use conflict consists of a complex, non-linear system of balancing and reinforcing feedback loops that recur across resource sectors. The conflicts are difficult to clearly define, have many interdependencies and are multi-causal. Specifically, dysfunctional policy, commoditisation of land, infringement on rights of users, shift from communal to private land ownership, renegotiation of rights, and unclear roles and responsibilities of government agencies, exacerbate conflicts among resource users, managers and policy makers in Ghana. In addition, supranational policy such as the protocol of the Economic Community of West African States, which promotes free movement of people and goods within the 16-nation community, is a driver of conflict between native farmers and nomadic Fulani herders. Clear policy directions from government that outlines the specific roles of various departments involved in resource issues together with a holistic community participatory approach is therefore required to comprehensively understand and address such conflicts.