A probabilistic approach for a cost-benefit analysis of oil spill management under uncertainty: A Bayesian network model for the Gulf of Finland

• Published in: Journal of environmental management 2015-08, Vol.158, p.122-132
• Main Authors: Helle, Inari, Ahtiainen, Heini, Luoma, Emilia, Hänninen, Maria, Kuikka, Sakari
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Bayes Theorem; Bayesian network; Benefit cost analysis; Cost-Benefit Analysis; Environmental impact; Environmental management; Environmental Restoration and Remediation - economics; Environmental valuation; Finland; Gulf of Finland; Humans; Maritime safety; Models, Statistical; Oceans and Seas; Oil spill; Oil spills; Petroleum Pollution - statistics & numerical data; Uncertainty; Water Pollution, Chemical - statistics & numerical data
• ISSN: 0301-4797; 1095-8630
• DOI: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2015.04.042

Large-scale oil accidents can inflict substantial costs to the society, as they typically result in expensive oil combating and waste treatment operations and have negative impacts on recreational and environmental values. Cost-benefit analysis (CBA) offers a way to assess the economic efficiency of management measures capable of mitigating the adverse effects. However, the irregular occurrence of spills combined with uncertainties related to the possible effects makes the analysis a challenging task. We develop a probabilistic modeling approach for a CBA of oil spill management and apply it in the Gulf of Finland, the Baltic Sea. The model has a causal structure, and it covers a large number of factors relevant to the realistic description of oil spills, as well as the costs of oil combating operations at open sea, shoreline clean-up, and waste treatment activities. Further, to describe the effects on environmental benefits, we use data from a contingent valuation survey. The results encourage seeking for cost-effective preventive measures, and emphasize the importance of the inclusion of the costs related to waste treatment and environmental values in the analysis. Although the model is developed for a specific area, the methodology is applicable also to other areas facing the risk of oil spills as well as to other fields that need to cope with the challenging combination of low probabilities, high losses and major uncertainties. •We develop a model for a cost-benefit analysis of oil spill management.•Uncertainty is explicitly taken into account in the model.•Both preventive and post-spill management measures are included in the analysis.•The benefits result from decreases in oil combating costs and environmental damages.•The results encourage seeking for cost-effective preventive measures.