Performance of M06, M06-2X, and M06-HF Density Functionals for Conformationally Flexible Anionic Clusters: M06 Functionals Perform Better than B3LYP for a Model System with Dispersion and Ionic Hydrogen-Bonding Interactions

• Published in: The journal of physical chemistry. A, Molecules, spectroscopy, kinetics, environment, & general theory Molecules, spectroscopy, kinetics, environment, & general theory, 2013-11, Vol.117 (47), p.12590-12600
• Main Authors: Walker, Martin, Harvey, Andrew J. A, Sen, Ananya, Dessent, Caroline E. H
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Arginine - chemistry; Atomic and molecular clusters; Atomic and molecular physics; Bromine - chemistry; Calculations and mathematical techniques in atomic and molecular physics (excluding electron correlation calculations); Charged clusters; Chlorine - chemistry; Clusters; Density; Density-functional theory; Dispersions; Electronic structure of atoms, molecules and their ions: theory; Errors; Exact sciences and technology; Functionals; Hydrofluoric Acid; Hydrogen Bonding; Ions - chemistry; Isomers; Mathematical models; Models, Molecular; Molecular Structure; Physics; Quantum Theory; Studies of special atoms, molecules and their ions; clusters; Tautomers
• ISSN: 1089-5639; 1520-5215
• DOI: 10.1021/jp408166m

We present a comparative assessment of the performance of the M06 suite of density functionals (M06, M06-2X, and M06-HF) against an MP2 benchmark for calculating the relative energies and geometric structures of the Cl–·arginine and Br–·arginine halide ion–amino acid clusters. Additional results are presented for the popular B3LYP density functional. The Cl–·arginine and Br–·arginine complexes are important prototypes for the phenomenon of anion-induced zwitterion formation. Results are presented for the canonical (noncharge separated) and zwitterionic (charge separated) tautomers of the clusters, as well as the numerous conformational isomers of the clusters. We find that all of the M06 functions perform well in terms of predicting the general trends in the conformer relative energies and identifying the global minimum conformer. This is in contrast to the B3LYP functional, which performed significantly less well for the canonical tautomers of the clusters where dispersion interactions contribute more significantly to the conformer energetics. We find that the M06 functional gave the lowest mean unsigned error for the relative energies of the canonical conformers (2.10 and 2.36 kJ/mol for Br–·arginine and Cl–·arginine), while M06-2X gave the lowest mean unsigned error for the zwitterionic conformers (0.85 and 1.23 kJ/mol for Br–·arginine and Cl–·arginine), thus providing insight into the types of physical systems where each of these functionals should perform best.