A simple method for fume cupboard performance assessment

• Published in: The Annals of occupational hygiene 2000-06, Vol.44 (4), p.291-300
• Main Authors: Nicholson, Graham P., Clark, Raymond P., Grover, Fred, de Calcina-Goff, Mervyn L.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Air Pollutants, Occupational; Applied sciences; Atmospheric pollution; Equipment Design; Exact sciences and technology; face velocity; fume cupboard; Humans; Indoor pollution and occupational exposure; Laboratories; Occupational Exposure - prevention & control; Pollution; ranking; United Kingdom; Ventilation - instrumentation; Ventilation - standards; visualisation
• ISSN: 0003-4878; 1475-3162
• DOI: 10.1016/S0003-4878(99)00107-6

The performance of a fume cupboard is determined by a complex interaction of factors which are time consuming and expensive to determine. This paper describes a simple and practical means of ranking, and assessing fume cupboard installations that can help to discharge managerial responsibility for a ‘safe’ environment. The method also gives an economically viable and technically defensible system for assessing fume cupboard performance as part of upgrading exercises or performance audits. The assessment strategy uses flow visualisation techniques and measurements of inflow air velocity as well as overall condition evaluation to rank performance and identify poor performing cupboards. The method has been used to carry out a condition and performance survey of 199 fume cupboards, both aerodynamic and box-type designs, in an academic institution. The results of this survey are presented which not only highlight performance characteristics but also provide insights into user attitudes and knowledge of fume cupboard operation and performance. It is suggested that surveys such as this could be helpful in training programmes for laboratory workers to enable them to optimise the use of fume cupboards.