Testing the Significance of Connectivity Networks: Comparison of Different Assessing Procedures

• Published in: IEEE transactions on biomedical engineering 2016-12, Vol.63 (12), p.2461-2473
• Main Authors: Toppi, Jlenia, Mattia, Donatella, Risetti, Monica, Formisano, Rita, Babiloni, Fabio, Astolfi, Laura
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Adult; Aged; Algorithms; Asymptotic properties; Asymptotic statistics; Brain; Brain - physiology; Brain - physiopathology; Brain Injuries, Traumatic - physiopathology; Brain modeling; causal Fourier transform (FT) shuffling; Coherence; Computational efficiency; Computational modeling; Computational neuroscience; Computing time; Connectivity; Consciousness; Data acquisition; Data models; Data processing; disorders of consciousness (DoC); EEG; Electroencephalography; Female; Humans; Male; Mathematical model; Middle Aged; Models, Neurological; Neural networks; Neural Pathways - physiology; Neural Pathways - physiopathology; partial directed coherence (PDC); Signal Processing, Computer-Assisted; Signal to noise ratio; Simulation; Sleep and wakefulness; Statistics; Stroke - physiopathology; Wakefulness
• ISSN: 0018-9294; 1558-2531
• DOI: 10.1109/TBME.2016.2621668

Despite the well-established use of partial directed coherence (PDC) to estimate interactions between brain signals, the assessment of its statistical significance still remains controversial. Commonly used approaches are based on the generation of empirical distributions of the null case, implying a considerable computational time, which may become a serious limitation in practical applications. Recently, rigorous asymptotic distributions for PDC were proposed. The aim of this work is to compare the performances of the asymptotic statistics with those of an empirical approach, in terms of both accuracy and computational time. Methods: Indices of performance were derived for the two approaches by a simulation study implementing different ground-truth networks under different levels of signal-to-noise ratio and amount of data available for the estimate. The two approaches were then applied to the resting-state EEG data acquired in a group of minimally conscious state and vegetative state/unresponsive wakefulness syndrome patients. Results: The performances of the asymptotic statistics in simulations matched those obtained by the empirical approach, with a considerable reduction of the computational time. Results of the application to real data showed that the asymptotic statistics led to the extraction of connectivity-based indices able to discriminate patients in different disorders of consciousness conditions and to correlate significantly with clinical scales. Such results were similar to those obtained by the empirical assessment, but with a considerable time economy. Significance: Asymptotic statistics provide an approach to the assessment of PDC significance with comparable performances with respect to the previously used empirical approaches but with a substantial advantage in terms of computational time.