Interpreting variation in fish-based food web indicators: the importance of “bottom-up limitation” and “top-down control” processes

• Published in: ICES journal of marine science 2014-01, Vol.71 (2), p.406-416
• Main Authors: Reilly, T, Fraser, H M, Fryer, R J, Clarke, J, Greenstreet, S P R
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Abundance; Biomass; Fish; Foods; Indicators; Marine; Predators; Webs
• ISSN: 1054-3139; 1095-9289
• DOI: 10.1093/icesjms/fst137

Proposed indicators for the Marine Strategy Framework Directive (MSFD) food webs Descriptor focus on structural elements of food webs, and in particular on the abundance and productivity of top predators. However, the inferences that can be drawn from such indicators depend on whether or not the predators are "bottom-up limited" by the availability of their prey. Many seabird populations appear to be "bottom-up limited" so that variation in their reproductive success and/or abundance reflects changes in lower trophic levels. Here we find that gadoid fish predators off the Firth of Forth, southeast Scotland, do not appear to be "bottom-up limited" by the biomass of their main prey, 0-group sandeels; gadoid biomass and feeding performance was independent of sandeel biomass. Variability in food web indicators based on these gadoid predators seems to impart little insight into underlying processes occurring at lower trophic levels in the local food web. The implications of this in terms of how the currently proposed MSFD food web indicators should be used and interpreted are considered, and the ramifications in terms of setting targets representing good environmental status for both fish and seabird communities are discussed.