Delivering dignified care: A realist synthesis of evidence that promotes effective listening to and learning from older people's feedback in acute care settings

• Published in: Journal of clinical nursing 2017-12, Vol.26 (23-24), p.4028-4038
• Main Authors: Dickson, Megan, Riddell, Helen, Gilmour, Fiona, McCormack, Brendan
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: acute care; assessment; communication; dignity; Feedback; Holistic nursing; Listening; Nursing; Nursing care; Older people; Patient-centered care; person‐centred care; relationships; Research methodology
• ISSN: 0962-1067; 1365-2702
• DOI: 10.1111/jocn.13856

Aims and objectives To explore effective mechanisms for listening to and learning from feedback from older people in the context of acute care. Background Maintaining the dignity of older people in acute care has become an issue of international concern. In the United Kingdom, recommendations for care improvement have led to the formation of an implementation group, the “Listening and Learning Hospitals Pilot Project.” This literature review forms phase 1 of the project. Design Realist synthesis was used to explore and synthesise wide‐ranging evidence. Methods Using 12 databases, literature was scoped to propose four principles that underpin the context, mechanism and outcomes (CMO) of effective relation‐based interventions with older people and their care partners in the acute care setting. A search was carried out in order to synthesise data to refute or support each principle. A total of 137 studies and 11 sources of grey literature were appraised and included. A final synthesis of evidence across all principles identified key mechanisms for effective relation‐based interventions. Results Eight essential mechanisms support effective care interventions. Conclusions This review adds depth and breadth to current nursing knowledge in this field through the process of realist synthesis. Acute care organisations need to make a commitment to supporting relational care at organisation and unit levels. Additionally, they need to value and support the well‐being of the nurses delivering it so that interventions to improve care for older people can succeed. Relevance to clinical practice Essential mechanisms synthesised from the review, together with other suggested interventions for improving dignified care of older people in acute care by listening to them and learning from their feedback, may contribute towards practice development in acute care.