Downscaling Aggregate Urban Metabolism Accounts to Local Districts

• Published in: Journal of industrial ecology 2017-04, Vol.21 (2), p.294-306
• Main Authors: Horta, Isabel M., Keirstead, James
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Accounts; Autocorrelation; Averages; Bayesian analysis; Cities; Consumption; Data collection; Data processing; Decision makers; econometrics; energy; Energy consumption; Energy efficiency; Geography; Global cities; Local government; London; Mapping; Measurement techniques; Metabolism; Methods; modeling; Multilevel; Normalization; Regression analysis; Residential energy; Resource consumption; Spatial distribution; Statistical methods; Studies; United States; Urban areas; Urban metabolism; Waste disposal; Water; Water resources
• ISSN: 1088-1980; 1530-9290
• DOI: 10.1111/jiec.12428

Summary Urban metabolism accounts of total annual energy, water, and other resource flows are increasingly available for a variety of world cities. For local decision makers, however, it may be important to understand the variations of resource consumption within the city. Given the difficulty of gathering suburban resource consumption data for many cities, this article investigates the potential of statistical downscaling methods to estimate local resource consumption using socioeconomic or other data sources. We evaluate six classes of downscaling methods: ratio‐based normalization; linear regression (both internally and externally calibrated); linear regression with spatial autocorrelation; multilevel linear regression; and a basic Bayesian analysis. The methods were applied to domestic energy consumption in London, UK, and our results show that it is possible to downscale aggregate resource consumption to smaller geographies with an average absolute prediction error of around 20%; however, performance varies widely by method, geography size, and fuel type. We also show how mapping these results can quickly identify districts with noteworthy resource consumption profiles. Further work should explore the design of local data collection strategies to enhance these methods and apply the techniques to other urban resources such as water or waste.