Elicitation by design in ecology: using expert opinion to inform priors for Bayesian statistical models

• Published in: Ecology (Durham) 2009, Vol.90 (1), p.265-277
• Main Authors: Choy, Samantha Low, O'Leary, Rebecca, Mengersen, Kerrie
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Animal and plant ecology; Animal, plant and microbial ecology; Animals; Applied ecology; Bayes Theorem; Bayesian analysis; Biological and medical sciences; Demography; Design; Ecological modeling; Ecology; Ecology - methods; Environmental assessment; Environmental Monitoring; expert elicitation; expert opinion; framework; Fundamental and applied biological sciences. Psychology; General aspects; Habitats; Human ecology; informative Bayesian analysis; learning; Macropodidae - physiology; Modeling; Models, Biological; Models, Statistical; motivation; Parametric models; prior information; Probabilities; protocol; statistical models; uncertainty; Vegetation
• ISSN: 0012-9658; 1939-9170
• DOI: 10.1890/07-1886.1

Bayesian statistical modeling has several benefits within an ecological context. In particular, when observed data are limited in sample size or representativeness, then the Bayesian framework provides a mechanism to combine observed data with other “prior” information. Prior information may be obtained from earlier studies, or in their absence, from expert knowledge. This use of the Bayesian framework reflects the scientific “learning cycle,” where prior or initial estimates are updated when new data become available. In this paper we outline a framework for statistical design of expert elicitation processes for quantifying such expert knowledge, in a form suitable for input as prior information into Bayesian models. We identify six key elements: determining the purpose and motivation for using prior information; specifying the relevant expert knowledge available; formulating the statistical model; designing effective and efficient numerical encoding; managing uncertainty; and designing a practical elicitation protocol. We demonstrate this framework applies to a variety of situations, with two examples from the ecological literature and three from our experience. Analysis of these examples reveals several recurring important issues affecting practical design of elicitation in ecological problems.