Nonphysical noises and instabilities in plasma simulation due to a spatial grid

• Published in: Journal of computational physics 1972-01, Vol.10 (3), p.475-486
• Main Author: Okuda, Hideo
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• ISSN: 0021-9991; 1090-2716
• DOI: 10.1016/0021-9991(72)90048-4

A series of plasma numerical simulation has been performed in order to understand the enhancement of nonphysical noises and instabilities due to the use of a spatial grid. Several different superparticle models including the Nearest Grid Point (NGP) model, Cloud-in-Cell (CIC) or Particle-in-Cell (PIC) models, Lewis energy conserving code, and the multipole expansion code have been examined for a Maxwellian plasma and a one beam plasma using a one-dimensional, one-specie (electron) plasma. An instability was observed for all of the models when the Debye length was too small compared with the grid size. When the Debye length is comparable to the grid size, no instabilities were observed. However, the enhancement of noises at high frequencies (ω > 3ω pe may not always be negligible- even for long wavelength modes for the NGP model. For the NGP and CIC, PIC models, the experimental results are in good agreement with Langdon's theory. It is observed that the dipole expansion model, which is the first-order approximation to the multipole expansion scheme, is similar to CIC, PIC models in many respects and appears to be the same order of approximation.