Flawed self‐assessment in hand hygiene: A major contributor to infections in clinical practice?

• Published in: Journal of clinical nursing 2019-06, Vol.28 (11-12), p.2265-2275
• Main Authors: Kelcikova, Simona, Mazuchova, Lucia, Bielena, Lubica, Filova, Lenka
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Attitudes; Clinical medicine; competence; Disease control; hand hygiene; hand hygiene noncompliance; hand hygiene‐related infections; Hands; Hygiene; Infections; Medical personnel; self‐assessment
• ISSN: 0962-1067; 1365-2702
• DOI: 10.1111/jocn.14823

Aim To assess the quality of self‐assessment and the attitude of healthcare workers (HCWs) to hand hygiene (HH) as possible factors of unsatisfactory HH compliance in clinical practice. Background Noncompliance of HH causes healthcare‐acquired infections (HAI) in patients. It is assumed that HH‐related infections make up approximately 80% of all infections in clinical practice. Our observations suggest that self‐assessment and attitude might be surprisingly important factors. Design and method The cross‐sectional approach using questionnaire and direct observation was applied. We followed STROBE guidelines. In total, questionnaires of 639 HCWs of surgical departments were included in the study, and 127 HCWs had been also directly observed. Results High self‐assessment regarding HH compliance and its knowledge was reported by 74% and 83% of HCWs, respectively. At the same time, only 51% of HCWs positively evaluated their colleagues with respect to HH. Similar to previous studies, we have found significant differences between physicians and nurses regarding the level of self‐assessment, attitude and perception of HH. Physicians were more critical in self‐assessment and considered HH less important compared to nurses. The observations revealed drawbacks in HH practices. The high level of self‐overassessment might be a contributing factor to noncompliance with HH. Conclusions It is necessary to establish systematic professional training and education of HCWs in relation to their HH, and to continuously monitor and evaluate the level of self‐assessment in clinical practice, mainly in surgery. Relevance to clinical practice A reasonable objective level of self‐assessment and attitude to HH are the most important conditions for preventing of HAI in patients.