Comparing the relationships between noise level and annoyance in different surveys: A railway noise vs. aircraft and road traffic comparison

• Published in: Journal of sound and vibration 1982-03, Vol.81 (1), p.51-80
• Main Authors: Fields, J.M., Walker, J.G.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• ISSN: 0022-460X; 1095-8568
• DOI: 10.1016/0022-460X(82)90177-8

Annoyance expressed in a railway noise survey is compared with that in two road traffic and three aircraft surveys in order to determine whether responses to various environmental noises are similar or are source-specific. Railway noise is less annoying than other noises at any given high noise level. Railway noise annoyance increases less rapidly with increasing noise level. At high noise levels this gap in reactions averages about 10 dB but ranges from 4 dB to more than 20 dB. Comparisons between the findings in the different surveys can be made only after considering differences in noise index calculation procedures, human response measurement procedures and annoyance moderating conditions. The methodology for comparing surveys is examined. It is found that methodological uncertainties lead to imprecise comparisons and that different annoyance scales give different estimates of intersurvey differences.