The influence of peer beliefs on nurses' use of new health information technology: A social network analysis

• Published in: Social science & medicine (1982) 2020-06, Vol.255, p.113002-8, Article 113002
• Main Authors: Yuan, Christina T., Nembhard, Ingrid M., Kane, Gerald C.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Bar code medication administration; Beliefs; Data collection; Drugs; Female; Health behavior; Health information; Health information technology; Homophily; Hospitals; Humans; Implementation; Influence; Information technology; Medical records; Medical technology; Medication Systems; Nurses; Peer beliefs; Peer Group; Peer groups; Peer relationships; Peers; Reinforcement; Social Network Analysis; Social networks; Surveys and Questionnaires; System use; United States; United States of America; Usefulness
• ISSN: 0277-9536; 1873-5347
• DOI: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2020.113002

Implementation of health information technology fails at an alarming rate because intended users often choose not to use it. Implementation theory and frameworks suggest that social networks may influence individuals' use, but empirical study remains limited. Furthermore, neither theory nor research has identified whose beliefs within the network matter most for implementation. We examine the relationship between an individual's system use and the beliefs of his or her peers. We assess the relationship for two peer groups: the entire group of peers and the subset that shares the individual's beliefs about the system. We used data collected from an academic hospital in the United States that had recently implemented a bar code medication administration system, a technology meant to increase medication safety. We administered a survey to nurses (N = 207) in six clinical units approximately 3–5 months (April–June 2013) after the “go-live” of the system to identify peer groups and beliefs about system usefulness. We calculated mean peer belief for the entire peer group and sharedness of belief using a homophily measure. From the hospital's electronic health record system, we obtained nurses' system use during the 3-month data collection period. We used multivariable linear regression to examine relationships. We found no effect of mean peer beliefs on individual system use. However, sharedness of belief about usefulness was positively associated with individual system use. Individuals' own positive belief was only associated with greater system use when shared with peers. Our findings indicate a significant role of social networks in implementation, and specifically that shared beliefs between an individual and his or her peer network may be critical to implementation success, more so than the beliefs across the entire peer group. Reinforcement by the social network appears to dictate whether individuals' own beliefs translate into system use. •First study to examine effects of peer beliefs on health information technology use.•When nurses shared positive beliefs about the technology with peers, use increased.•Reinforcement by peers appears to translate individual's own beliefs into action.