Clinical utility of plain-film abdominal radiographs for inpatients outside standard working hours in a large university teaching hospital

• Published in: Radiography (London, England. 1995) England. 1995), 2021-02, Vol.27 (1), p.132-135
• Main Authors: McAnena, P.F., Moloney, B.M., McAnena, O.J., Kerin, M.J., McCarthy, P.A.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Abdominal X-ray; Cost; Inpatient; Outside normal working hours; Radiation
• ISSN: 1078-8174; 1532-2831
• DOI: 10.1016/j.radi.2020.07.003

Plain film abdominal radiographs (PFAs) are frequently the initial investigation ordered for patients with abdominal symptoms. However, increasing use of emergency ultrasound and availability of emergency CT raises the question of whether PFA remains an appropriate first line investigation. We investigated the impact of out of hours (OOH) PFAs on inpatient management. All consecutive PFAs over an 8-week period were included to determine the impact on patient management. OOH was classified as from 5pm to 9am Monday to Friday, weekends and bank-holidays. PACS and hospital records were accessed to determine patient pathways. The institution is a tertiary referral centre with 850 acute beds and serves a population of 950,000. A total of 758 consecutive PFAs were performed in total (58.3% male, mean age 58.1 (range 0–93)). 310 (40.9%) were requested from the emergency department (ED) and 382 (50.4%) were requested from wards. 160 (21.1%) met the criteria of OOH, of these 120 (72.2%) were from ED and 28 were on adult inpatients. Of these 28, none had a change in management based on the PFA result. Our study suggests that OOH PFAs of inpatients are of limited clinical utility. These patients are exposed to extra radiation. We propose that OOH PFAs of inpatients should be questioned as a viable investigation due to the limited contribution they offer in managing patients, the deleterious effects they confer on the patient and the associated economic cost. Further studies are needed to assess if these results are generalizable to other large hospitals.