Evaluating recall error in preschoolers: Category expectations influence episodic memory for color

• Published in: Cognitive psychology 2021-02, Vol.124, p.101357-101357, Article 101357
• Main Authors: Persaud, Kimele, Macias, Carla, Hemmer, Pernille, Bonawitz, Elizabeth
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Cognitive development; Color categories; Episodic memory; Prior category knowledge; Probabilistic models; Relational memory
• ISSN: 0010-0285; 1095-5623
• DOI: 10.1016/j.cogpsych.2020.101357

•We investigate developmental differences in how color categories are used in recall.•Like adults, children’s recall shows regression to the category mean effects.•In the aggregate, an integrated category and episodic model best fits children’s data.•Individually, children freely use category labels and a category only model fits best.•Results suggest category use in memory comes online early and strongly in development. Despite limited memory capacity, children are exceptional learners. How might children engage in meaningful learning despite limited memory systems? Past research suggests that adults integrate category knowledge and noisy episodic traces to aid recall when episodic memory is noisy or incomplete (e.g. Hemmer & Steyvers, 2009a,b). We suspect children utilize a similar process but integrate category and episodic traces in recall to a different degree. Here we conduct two experiments to empirically assess children’s color category knowledge (Study 1) and recall of target hue values (Study 2). In Study 1, although children’s generated hue values appear to be noisier than adults, we found no significant difference between children and adult’s generated color category means (prototypes), suggesting that preschool-aged children’s color categories are well established. In Study 2, we found that children’s (like adult’s) free recall of target hue values regressed towards color category means. We implemented three probabilistic memory models: one that combines category knowledge and specific target information (Integrative), a category only (Noisy Prototype) model, and a target only (Noisy Target) model to computationally evaluate recall performance. Consistent with previous studies with older children (Duffy, Huttenlocher, & Crawford, 2006), quantitative fits of the models to aggregate group-level data provided strong support for the Integrative process. However, at the individual subject level, a greater proportion of preschoolers’ recall was better fit by a Prototype only model. Our results provide evidence that the integration of category knowledge in episodic memory comes online early and strongly. Implications for how the greater reliance on category knowledge by preschoolers relative to adults might track with developmental shifts in relational episodic memory are discussed.