The experiences of nurses and midwives who provide surgical abortion care: A qualitative systematic review

• Published in: Journal of advanced nursing 2021-09, Vol.77 (9), p.3644-3656
• Main Authors: Qian, Jia‐lu, Pan, Pang‐e, Wu, Meng‐wei, Zheng, Qiong, Sun, Shi‐wen, Liu, Lu, Sun, Ya‐ping, Yu, Xiao‐yan
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Abortion; Bereavement; Clinical medicine; Clinical standards; Coping; Coping strategies; Debriefing; Emotional labor; Emotional support; Medical personnel; Mental health; Midwifery; Midwives; Nurses; Nursing; Occupational stress; Optimization; Pain; Professional development; Professional training; Professionalism; Psychological well being; Qualitative research; qualitative synthesis; Roles; Systematic review; Work skills; Workshops
• ISSN: 0309-2402; 1365-2648
• DOI: 10.1111/jan.14853

Aim To synthesize qualitative evidence on nurses' and midwives' experiences in the provision of surgical abortion care. We address three specific questions: (a) what are the experiences of nurses and midwives in surgical abortion care? (b) what are their responses and coping strategies? (c) what are the deficiencies in surgical abortion care? Design Qualitative studies were synthesized using Thomas and Harden's qualitative thematic synthesis method. Data sources Electronic databases, including PubMed, Embase, CINAHL, PsycINFO, Scopus and Web of Science were searched. Grey literature using ProQuest was searched. The databases were searched from inception to 5 August 2020. Review methods The SPIDER (Sample, Phenomenon of Interest, Design, Evaluation and Research type) search tool was used in the literature search. Data synthesis was conducted using the three‐stage thematic synthesis method described by Thomas and Harden. Results 966 studies were identified in the initial search and 18 studies were included. Four analytical themes were generated: ‘Providing abortion care requires high emotional labour’; ‘Professionalism of abortion care providers’; ‘Initiatives in professional development’ and ‘Improving directions for high‐quality abortion care’. Conclusion Nurses and midwives indicated that they require support to enhance psychological health and improve professional skills. Hospital managers should organize regular debriefing or structured group workshops for exchange of practical experiences and strengthening emotional support. More research is required to establish comprehensive training related to abortion care for nurses and midwives. The findings demonstrate that optimization of abortion services should start from hospital management models, pain management and bereavement care. Impact Understanding the experiences of nurses and midwives in abortion provision will inform future clinical practice in surgical abortion care, which would be helpful in improving the professionalism and confidence of abortion providers. Our findings have implications for the training, development of policies and standards for surgical abortion care for nurses and midwives.