Congruence between the prioritisation of conservation problems at the local and national scale: an evaluation by environmental scientists in Poland

• Published in: Environmental science and pollution research international 2021-07, Vol.28 (27), p.35317-35326
• Main Authors: Skórka, Piotr, Banach, Agata, Banasiak, Marek, Bokalska-Rajba, Joanna, Bonk, Maciej, Czachura, Paweł, García-Rodríguez, Alberto, Gaspar, Gabriela, Hordyńska, Natalia, Kaczmarczyk, Adriana, Kapłoniak, Kamila, Kociński, Maciej, Łopata, Barbara, Mazur, Edyta, Mirzaei, Mohamadreza, Misiewicz, Anna, Parres, Aida, Przystałkowska, Anna, Pustkowiak, Sylwia, Raczyński, Mateusz, Sadura, Iwona, Splitt, Aleksandra, Stanek, Małgorzata, Sternalski, Jakub, Wierzbicka, Alicja, Wiorek, Marcin, Zduńczyk, Paweł
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Anthropogenic factors; Aquatic Pollution; Atmospheric Protection/Air Quality Control/Air Pollution; Biodiversity; Conservation; Conservation of Natural Resources; Cross-Sectional Studies; Data mining; Delphi method; Earth and Environmental Science; Ecotoxicology; Environment; Environmental Chemistry; Environmental Health; Environmental policy; Environmental science; Forest management; Forestry; Frequency analysis; Humans; Poland; Trend Editorial; Urbanization; Waste Water Technology; Water Management; Water Pollution Control
• ISSN: 0944-1344; 1614-7499
• DOI: 10.1007/s11356-021-14741-5

The anthropogenic pressure on the environment depends on the spatial scale. It is crucial to prioritise conservation actions at different spatial scales to be cost-efficient. Using horizon scanning with the Delphi technique, we asked what the most important conservation problems are in Poland at local and national scales. Twenty-six participants, PhD students, individually identified conservation issues important at the local and national scales. Each problem was then scored and classified into broader categories during the round discussions. Text mining, cross-sectional analyses, and frequency tests were used to compare the context, importance scores, and frequency of identified problems between the two scales, respectively. A total of 115 problems were identified at the local scale and 122 at the national scale. Among them, 30 problems were identical for both scales. Importance scores were higher for national than local problems; however, this resulted from different sets of problems identified at the two scales. Problems linked to urbanisation, education, and management were associated with the local scale. Problems related to policy, forestry, and consumerism were more frequent at the national scale. An efficient conservation policy should be built hierarchically (e.g. introducing adaptive governance), implementing solutions at a national scale with the flexibility to adjust for local differences and to address the most pressing issues.